logo Mon, 23 Dec 2024 13:36:20 GMT

The Science Delusion


Synopsis


NEW EDITION

The Science Delusion is the belief that science already understands the nature of reality. The fundamental questions are answered, leaving only the details to be filled in. In this book (published in the US as Science Set Free), Dr Rupert Sheldrake, one of the world's most innovative scientists, shows that science is being constricted by assumptions that have hardened into dogmas. The 'scientific worldview' has become a belief system. All reality is material or physical. The world is a machine, made up of dead matter. Nature is purposeless. Consciousness is nothing but the physical activity of the brain. Free will is an illusion. God exists only as an idea in human minds, imprisoned within our skulls.

Sheldrake examines these dogmas scientifically, and shows persuasively that science would be better off without them: freer, more interesting, and more fun.

In The God Delusion Richard Dawkins used science to bash God, but here Rupert Sheldrake shows that Dawkins' understanding of what science can do is old-fashioned and itself a delusion.

'Rupert Sheldrake does science, humanity and the world at large a considerable favour.'
The Independent

'Certainly we need to accept the limitations of much current dogma and keep our minds open as we reasonably can. Sheldrake may help us do so through this well-written, challenging and always interesting book.'
Financial Times

Summary

Chapter 1: The God Hypothesis

* Dawkins argues that the popular conception of God as a conscious creator is not supported by scientific evidence.
* He introduces the "god of the gaps," the idea that God exists to explain phenomena that we cannot yet understand scientifically.
* Real example: Dawkins cites the example of the theory of evolution, which has replaced the need for a creator to explain the diversity of life on Earth.

Chapter 2: Holy Ignorance

* Dawkins accuses religious apologists of using ignorance as a justification for belief in God.
* He argues that it is irrational to believe in something simply because we do not know the answer.
* Real example: Dawkins criticizes the argument that the existence of complex biological systems proves the existence of a designer, since complexity can arise naturally through evolutionary processes.

Chapter 3: A Universe with a Purpose

* Dawkins examines the teleological argument, which claims that the universe must have a purpose because it appears to be fine-tuned for life.
* He argues that this argument is flawed because it relies on a limited understanding of the vastness of the universe.
* Real example: Dawkins points out that the scale of the universe makes it highly improbable that Earth is the only planet capable of supporting life.

Chapter 4: Beyond the Beholder

* Dawkins argues that beauty and morality are not objective properties of the universe but rather subjective creations of the human mind.
* He claims that the idea of an external source of these values is an illusion.
* Real example: Dawkins discusses the different cultural interpretations of beauty, showing that there is no universal standard.

Chapter 5: The Four Horsemen

* Dawkins identifies four key factors that he believes contribute to religious belief: fear, ignorance, tribe, and authority.
* He argues that these factors can lead people to embrace irrational and harmful ideas.
* Real example: Dawkins cites the religious wars and persecutions throughout history as examples of the dangers of religious belief.

Chapter 6: The Quest for Comfort

* Dawkins acknowledges that religion can provide comfort and support for people in times of need.
* However, he argues that this comfort is based on a false sense of security and can lead to complacency and inaction.
* Real example: Dawkins suggests that religious beliefs can discourage critical thinking and prevent people from addressing real problems.

Chapter 7: Is Science a Religion?

* Dawkins refutes the argument that science is a form of religion.
* He explains that science is a method of inquiry that relies on evidence and logical reasoning, while religion is based on faith and dogma.
* Real example: Dawkins compares the process of scientific inquiry to the development of religious beliefs, showing that they have fundamentally different approaches to knowledge.

Chapter 8: Scientists as Prophets

* Dawkins argues that scientists have played a significant role in promoting human progress and well-being.
* He emphasizes the importance of scientific skepticism and the need to resist the influence of religious dogma in decision-making.
* Real example: Dawkins cites the contributions of scientists like Charles Darwin, Albert Einstein, and Stephen Hawking to our understanding of the world.

Chapter 9: The Illusions of Immortality

* Dawkins examines the concept of immortality and argues that it is an illusion created by religious belief.
* He explains that life is finite and that the desire for eternal life is driven by fear of death.
* Real example: Dawkins discusses the biological and psychological reasons why humans are afraid of death.

Chapter 10: The Consolation of Philosophy

* Dawkins concludes by offering an alternative to religious belief: the pursuit of knowledge and understanding.
* He emphasizes the importance of critical thinking, compassion, and ethical behavior.
* Real example: Dawkins suggests that philosophical and scientific inquiry can provide a sense of meaning and purpose in life without the need for religious dogma.