logo Tue, 24 Dec 2024 00:08:29 GMT

Letter to the Father


Synopsis


A son's poignant letter to his father-from the author of The Metamorphosis and The Trial, and one of the most important writers of the twentieth century.  "One of the great confessions of literature." -The New York Times Book Review

Franz Kafka wrote this letter to his father, Hermann Kafka, in November 1919. Max Brod, Kafka's literary executor, relates that Kafka actually gave the letter to his mother to hand to his father, hoping it might renew a relationship that had lost itself in tension and frustration on both sides. But Kafka's probing of the deep flaw in their relationship spared neither his father nor himself. He could not help seeing the failure of communication between father and son as another moment in the larger existential predicament depicted in so much of his work. Probably realizing the futility of her son's gesture, Julie Kafka did not deliver the letter but instead returned it to its author.

Franz Kafka (author), Ernst Kaiser (translator), Eithne Wilkins (translator), Franz Kafka

Summary

Chapter 1: The Letter

Franz Kafka writes an open letter to his father, Hermann, expressing his profound ambivalence and resentment towards him. Kafka describes his father as a domineering and overbearing figure who has instilled in him a sense of inadequacy and insecurity. He recounts specific incidents and childhood experiences that illustrate the damaging nature of their relationship.

Example:

"My dearest father,
I am writing to you because there is something I need to say that I have been unable to express to you in person. I have always been afraid of you, and I still am. You have always been so strong and dominating, while I have always felt weak and inadequate in your presence."

Chapter 2: The Authority Figure

Kafka explores the power dynamic between father and son, arguing that Hermann's authoritarian parenting style has stifled his own development. He describes his father as a source of constant anxiety and disapproval, who has crushed his creativity and individuality.

Example:

"You have always treated me like a subordinate, like someone who is inferior to you. You have never allowed me to express my own opinions or to make my own decisions. You have always told me what to do and how to think, and I have always obeyed because I was afraid of your wrath."

Chapter 3: The Father's Legacy

Kafka examines the lasting impact of his relationship with his father on his life and writing. He argues that Hermann's negative influence has contributed to his feelings of guilt, anxiety, and self-doubt. He also suggests that his father's overbearing presence has cast a shadow over his literary pursuits.

Example:

"Your shadow has always loomed over me, and I have never been able to escape it. I have tried to write, to express myself, but your voice is always there, telling me that I am not good enough, that I will never be good enough."

Chapter 4: The Search for Independence

Despite his profound resentment, Kafka acknowledges his father's positive qualities and the sacrifices he made for his family. He expresses a desire to reconcile with Hermann and to find some measure of peace in their relationship.

Example:

"I do not want to blame you for everything. I know that you had your own struggles, and that you did the best you could. I know that you loved me, in your own way. But your love was not enough. It was not the kind of love that I needed."

Chapter 5: The Letter's Impact

Kafka wrote the letter to his father in 1919 but never sent it. However, it was published posthumously and has since become a powerful and thought-provoking exploration of the complex relationship between fathers and sons.

Example:

"I have written this letter to you, but I do not know if you will ever read it. I do not know if you will ever understand it. But I had to write it, for my own sake. I had to say what I have been saying to you all my life, but never out loud."